Sales Coaching Plan AI Prompts for Managers

Quick Answer

We provide a strategic AI-powered framework for managers to diagnose and resolve sales underperformance. Our approach moves beyond generic feedback to identify root causes using a data-driven ‘Three P’s’ model (Problems, Process, Psychology). This guide offers actionable AI prompts to transform struggling reps into top performers, ensuring revenue growth and team retention.

Benchmarks

The Modern Manager’s Guide to Turning Around Underperformance

You see the numbers. The pipeline is thin, forecasts are being missed, and you know exactly which rep is at the center of the storm. This isn’t just a performance issue; it’s a leadership crucible. You’re juggling your own targets, and the thought of another “performance improvement plan” conversation fills you with dread. It’s a cycle many managers know too well: the lack of a structured coaching framework, the crippling time constraints, and the emotional weight of these critical conversations. The stakes are incredibly high. According to research from the Sales Management Association, teams with structured coaching programs see revenue growth that is 28% higher than their peers. More importantly, effective coaching is the single biggest factor in rep retention, saving you the immense cost and disruption of replacing a trained team member.

This is where the modern manager needs a new playbook. The solution isn’t to work more hours or to become a therapist; it’s to augment your innate leadership skills with a powerful co-pilot: AI. Think of it as a strategic sparring partner that helps you structure your thoughts, ensures your feedback is consistent and unbiased, and provides data-driven insights you might have missed. It transforms a daunting, emotionally charged task into a manageable, strategic process. You remain the coach, but AI becomes your playbook designer and performance analyst.

This guide is your step-by-step framework for turning that struggling rep into a top performer. We will move beyond generic advice and give you a precise, actionable path forward. You’ll learn how to use specific AI prompts to diagnose the true root cause of underperformance, collaboratively build a concrete development plan that resonates with the rep, and establish a clear system for tracking progress. By the end, you’ll have a repeatable system for turning these challenging situations into success stories, backed by the strategic power of AI.

The Foundation: Diagnosing the Root Cause Before Prescribing a Solution

“You’re not hitting your quota.” These are five of the most useless words in management. They state a fact but offer no path forward, only a judgment. Delivering this feedback is like a doctor telling a patient they’re sick without asking about their symptoms. The real work—the coaching that actually drives change—begins long before you ever have that performance conversation. It starts with a rigorous, empathetic diagnostic process. Before you can build a plan, you must understand the “why” behind the underperformance.

Surface-level diagnoses lead to surface-level solutions. If you assume the problem is a lack of effort and you push for more activity, you might be ignoring a critical skill gap. If you prescribe a new sales script for someone struggling with burnout, you’re just adding to their cognitive load. In my experience managing teams, I’ve found that most underperformance stems from one of three areas, a framework I call the Three P’s:

• Problems (Skill Gaps): The rep lacks the necessary knowledge or ability. This could be anything from poor product knowledge and an inability to handle objections to a failure to grasp the nuances of MEDDICC. They might be working hard but simply don’t know how to be effective.
• Process (Workflow Issues): The system is failing the rep. Their territory is poorly defined, the CRM is a mess of inaccurate data, or they’re spending 70% of their time on administrative tasks instead of selling. No amount of skill can overcome a broken process.
• Psychology (Motivation & Mindset): The rep’s internal state is the barrier. This is the most complex and often the most critical “P.” It includes burnout, a lack of belief in the product, imposter syndrome, or external personal issues affecting their focus. This is where a manager must become a coach, not a taskmaster.

The Data-Driven Discovery Phase

Before you say a word to the rep, you need to become an investigator. Your goal is to move from anecdotes to evidence. Relying on a “gut feeling” is one of the costliest mistakes a manager can make. It introduces bias and often leads to misdiagnosing the issue entirely. Instead, you need to gather objective data points to find patterns of behavior.

Your investigation should start with the tools you already have:

• CRM Data: Don’t just look at the final number. Dig into the leading indicators. Are their conversion rates from one stage to the next significantly lower than the team average? Is their activity level (calls, emails) high, but their meeting-to-opportunity ratio low? This points to a quality-over-quantity issue, often a skill gap.
• Call Recordings: This is your ground truth. Listen to a representative sample of their calls—a few wins, but especially the losses. Are they talking over the prospect? Failing to ask discovery questions? Not effectively linking product features to the prospect’s pain points? You’re looking for repeatable mistakes, not one-off bad days.
• Pipeline Health: A rep might be hitting their activity metrics but have a pipeline full of unqualified, low-probability deals. This is a classic sign of a rep who is busy but not effective, often stemming from a fear of rejection that leads them to avoid tough qualification conversations.

The key is to look for patterns, not single data points. One lost deal is a data point; five lost deals where the rep failed to identify the economic buyer is a pattern. This evidence forms the objective foundation for your conversation.

The Empathetic Inquiry Phase

Armed with your data, you can now approach the rep not with accusations, but with observations and questions. This initial conversation is the most critical step. Your primary job is to listen, not to talk. The goal is to create psychological safety so the rep feels comfortable sharing the real obstacles they’re facing.

Structure the conversation with a framework of open-ended inquiry:

1. Start with Observation, Not Judgment: Instead of “Your conversion rate is low,” try “I’ve noticed in the last few weeks that deals tend to stall after the demo stage. I’m curious what you’re seeing from your side.” This invites collaboration.
2. Ask Open-Ended Questions: Use questions that can’t be answered with a simple “yes” or “no.”
   • “Walk me through your process for a typical deal.”
   • “Which part of the sales cycle feels the most challenging for you right now, and why?”
   • “If you had a magic wand to change one thing about your territory or our process to help you succeed, what would it be?”
3. Practice Active Listening: Pay attention to what’s said, but also to what’s not said. Are they hesitant? Do they blame external factors exclusively? Listen for the hidden obstacles that data can’t reveal. I once had a rep whose numbers plummeted. The data suggested laziness. But in a conversation framed around process, he revealed he was spending three hours a day manually cleaning up CRM data from a broken integration, leading to complete burnout. The data told me what was happening; the conversation told me why.

This human element is where you connect the Three P’s. The data might show a skill gap (Problems), but the conversation reveals it’s because the rep is burned out from a process issue (Process), which is causing a crisis of confidence (Psychology). You can’t solve the right problem until you understand this interplay.

AI Prompt for Root Cause Analysis

Synthesizing all this information—quantitative data from the CRM, qualitative notes from call reviews, and nuanced insights from your conversation—can be overwhelming. This is a perfect use case for an AI co-pilot. It can act as an unbiased analyst, helping you connect the dots and formulate a hypothesis about the root cause. It won’t replace your judgment, but it will sharpen it.

Here is a powerful prompt you can use to synthesize your findings:

AI Prompt: “Act as an expert sales coach. I need you to analyze the following information about an underperforming sales representative and synthesize the potential root causes.

Objective Data:

• CRM Metrics: [e.g., Quota attainment is 60%. Conversion rate from Stage 2 (Discovery) to Stage 3 (Demo) is 15%, vs. team average of 30%. Activity levels are high (120 calls/week).]
• Call Recording Notes: [e.g., Rep is good at building rapport but struggles with objection handling, specifically around price. Often gives discounts too early. Fails to ask about budget.]

Subjective Data (from conversation):

• Rep’s Stated Challenges: [e.g., “I feel like prospects are just kicking the tires,” “I don’t think our product can actually do what marketing promises.”]
• My Observations: [e.g., Rep seems disengaged in team meetings, mentioned a heavy personal workload recently.]

Based on this data, please:

1. Identify the most likely root cause(s) using the ‘Three P’s’ framework (Problems, Process, Psychology).
2. Explain the reasoning, connecting specific data points to your conclusion.
3. Suggest 2-3 key areas for deeper investigation in my next 1-on-1 with the rep.”

By using AI for this step, you move from raw data and feelings to a structured, evidence-based hypothesis. This ensures your coaching plan targets the actual disease, not just the symptoms, dramatically increasing your chances of a successful turnaround.

Structuring the Conversation: AI Prompts for a Constructive Coaching Dialogue

An underperforming rep walks into your office, and you can feel the tension. You know the meeting is necessary, but the fear of demotivating them—or worse, having them shut down completely—hangs in the air. How do you transform this dreaded confrontation into a productive, forward-looking dialogue? The secret isn’t in what you say, but in how you structure the entire interaction, from the first “hello” to the final action item.

This is where many managers stumble. They jump straight to the performance gap, armed with data, and inadvertently create an adversarial dynamic. The rep feels attacked, and the conversation becomes a defensive exercise rather than a developmental one. A successful coaching dialogue is a carefully architected experience. It requires setting the right psychological stage, using objective communication frameworks, and guiding the rep to their own breakthroughs. By leveraging AI as a strategic co-pilot, you can prepare for this delicate dance with confidence, ensuring every conversation is a step toward a solution, not a deeper problem.

Setting the Stage for Success

The success of a coaching conversation is often determined before it even begins. Logistics and psychology are intertwined; ignoring one undermines the other. Your first consideration should always be the environment. Never have a performance conversation in a public space or a busy open-plan office. A private meeting room or a one-on-one video call with cameras on is non-negotiable. This signals respect and confidentiality, creating a safe container for a vulnerable conversation.

Next, consider the timing and framing. A surprise “we need to talk” message can trigger days of anxiety. Instead, provide a clear, neutral agenda. An invitation like, “Let’s connect on Tuesday to review Q3 goals and map out a plan for the rest of the year,” frames the meeting as collaborative and future-focused. It sets the expectation that this is a strategic planning session, not a disciplinary hearing. From the moment they receive the invitation, you should be working to establish a collaborative, not punitive, tone. This is a golden nugget for experienced managers: the rep’s mindset going into the meeting is half the battle. If they feel they are walking into a partnership to solve a problem, they will bring solutions; if they feel they are walking into a trial, they will bring defenses.

The “Situation-Behavior-Impact” (SBI) Model

When you finally sit down to talk, the words you choose are critical. Vague feedback like “your performance has been slipping” or “you need to be more proactive” is unhelpful and invites defensiveness. This is where the “Situation-Behavior-Impact” (SBI) model becomes your most powerful tool for delivering specific, objective, and non-judgmental feedback. It’s a framework that removes accusation and focuses on observable reality.

Here’s how it works:

• Situation: Describe the specific context. Where and when did this happen? Example: “During the client demo last Tuesday morning…”
• Behavior: Describe the exact, observable action or inaction. Avoid interpretations or judgments. Example: “…when the client asked about integration capabilities, you said you’d get back to them instead of using the pre-approved slide deck we have for that exact question.”
• Impact: Explain the consequence of the behavior on the team, the client, or the business. Example: “…the impact was that the client’s momentum was broken, and it introduced doubt about our product’s capabilities, which put us on the defensive for the rest of the call.”

Notice how SBI focuses on the what, not the why. It doesn’t accuse the rep of being unprepared or lazy. It simply states a fact and its consequence. This approach opens the door for a productive discussion about the “why” together, rather than forcing the rep to defend against your assumptions. It’s the difference between saying “You’re not a team player” (a judgment) and “When you didn’t share the updated contact list before the team meeting, the new reps couldn’t prepare for their calls” (SBI). The latter is irrefutable and solution-oriented.

AI Prompts for Conversation Scripts & Scenarios

Even with a solid framework like SBI, it can be difficult to find the right words in the moment. This is where AI excels as a rehearsal partner. You can use it to generate scripts, anticipate emotional reactions, and practice your delivery. Think of it as a flight simulator for difficult conversations.

Here are specific prompts you can use to prepare:

• To craft your opening:

  “Generate a script for opening a coaching conversation about low prospect engagement. The rep, ‘Alex,’ has been logging calls but not converting them to meetings. Use the SBI model to frame the initial feedback. The goal is a collaborative discussion, so the tone should be inquisitive and supportive, not accusatory. Start by stating the purpose of the meeting is to understand his experience and build a plan together.”

• To prepare for defensiveness:

  “Create three potential responses if Alex becomes defensive and says, ‘It’s not my fault, marketing’s leads are terrible.’ For each response, provide a follow-up question that acknowledges his frustration but gently pivots the conversation back to his own actions and within his control, without being dismissive.”

• To practice active listening:

  “I’m about to ask Alex to describe the challenges he’s facing. Generate five open-ended, empathetic questions I can ask to get him to elaborate on his perspective, moving beyond one-word answers. For example, instead of ‘Are you finding the new script difficult?’ ask ‘Walk me through how you’re using the new script on a typical call.’”

Using these prompts allows you to walk into the meeting with a mental map of where the conversation could go. You’re not scripting the entire interaction, but you’re prepared for the likely emotional and logical turns, which allows you to stay calm and guide the process effectively.

Co-Creating the Solution

The ultimate goal of the coaching conversation is not for the rep to simply agree with your assessment. It’s for them to take ownership of their improvement plan. The moment you tell someone what they need to do, you invite resistance. The moment you ask them what they think they should do, you invite commitment. Your role shifts from a director to a facilitator.

This is the co-creation phase, and it’s where the real magic happens. After you’ve used SBI to lay out the objective feedback and listened to their perspective, the conversation should pivot to questions that empower them to generate the solution.

Use AI to help you brainstorm these powerful, open-ended questions:

“I’ve just finished explaining the ‘Impact’ portion of my SBI feedback regarding a rep’s failure to follow up on hot leads. Now, I need to shift to co-creating a solution. Generate five powerful, open-ended questions that will guide the rep to self-identify the root cause and propose their own action plan. Questions should encourage ownership, for example: ‘Based on our conversation, what’s one thing you could start doing differently this week?’ or ‘What support or resources do you feel would make the biggest difference for you right now?’”

By asking these questions, you are signaling your trust in their ability to solve their own problems. When the rep themselves says, “I think I need to block out two hours every morning for dedicated follow-ups,” that’s a far more powerful commitment than you simply telling them to do it. This process fosters buy-in, builds accountability, and transforms a moment of underperformance into a catalyst for genuine, self-motivated growth.

Building the Actionable Development Plan: From Diagnosis to Daily Execution

You’ve diagnosed the performance gap and had the initial conversation. Now comes the moment where most coaching plans fall apart: creating a plan that actually works. A vague directive like “do more discovery” is a recipe for failure. It offers no clear direction, no way to measure progress, and leaves both you and your rep frustrated. The real work is translating that diagnosis into a structured, executable roadmap that bridges the gap between their current state and their potential.

The Anatomy of an Effective Sales Development Plan

An effective development plan isn’t a document you file away; it’s a living guide for daily action. To ensure it has teeth, every component must be built on the SMART framework. This isn’t just corporate jargon; it’s a practical tool for eliminating ambiguity. Here’s what that looks like in a sales context:

• Specific: Vague goals produce vague results. Instead of “improve negotiation,” a specific goal is “Master the three-step value reiteration framework to defend price on deals over $10k.” This tells the rep exactly what skill to practice and what success looks like.
• Measurable: If you can’t track it, you can’t improve it. Attach a clear metric. For example, “Increase the number of qualified discovery calls from 5 to 8 per week.” This provides objective proof of progress and removes guesswork from performance reviews.
• Achievable: The goal must challenge the rep without crushing their morale. Setting a target to “Close 5 new enterprise deals in 30 days” for a rep who has never done so is demotivating. A more achievable target might be “Secure 3 discovery calls with Director-level contacts at target accounts within the next two weeks.”
• Relevant: The skill being developed must directly impact the rep’s core responsibilities and the team’s overall objectives. If the team’s primary goal is to break into a new market segment, the plan should focus on skills related to that segment, not on closing small, existing-logo deals faster.
• Time-bound: A goal without a deadline is just a wish. A plan needs a clear start and end date to create urgency and focus. “By the end of Q3, you will complete the negotiation training module and apply the framework on all relevant calls.”

Golden Nugget: A common mistake is creating a plan in a vacuum. The most effective plans are co-created with the rep. This simple shift transforms the plan from a disciplinary action into a collaborative investment in their success, dramatically increasing buy-in and accountability.

AI Prompts for Generating SMART Goals

The hardest part of creating a SMART plan is often the initial translation from a general observation into a concrete, measurable goal. This is where AI can act as an expert sounding board, helping you structure your thoughts and propose multiple options. You start with your observation, and the AI helps you build the scaffolding.

For instance, you’ve identified that an underperforming rep struggles with discovery calls. They ask surface-level questions and fail to uncover the prospect’s core business pain. A manager might be tempted to just say, “Ask better questions.” Instead, use AI to build a structured plan.

Try this prompt:

“Act as an experienced sales manager. An underperforming rep struggles with discovery calls; they ask surface-level questions and fail to uncover the prospect’s core business pain. Create three distinct SMART goals to improve their discovery skills over the next 30 days. Each goal should focus on a different aspect: one on preparation, one on execution during the call, and one on post-call documentation.”

The AI might generate goals like these:

1. Preparation: “By the end of next week, the rep will use the provided company research template to create a 3-point hypothesis for every discovery call, identifying potential business pains before the call begins. This will be reviewed by the manager for 100% of calls for the next two weeks.”
2. Execution: “For the next 15 discovery calls, the rep will use at least three ‘problem-agitation’ questions (e.g., ‘What is the cost of that problem to the business?’) and document the prospect’s answers in the CRM call notes. We will review call recordings to track this metric.”
3. Documentation: “Within 24 hours of each discovery call, the rep will update the CRM opportunity record with a summary of the identified business pain, the quantified impact, and the next agreed-upon step. This will be measured by a 95% compliance rate over the next 30 days.”

Designing Targeted Training & Practice

Goals are the destination, but training and practice are the vehicle to get there. A plan is incomplete without a curriculum of activities designed to build the specific skills identified in your SMART goals. This moves beyond passive learning (like watching a video) to active skill-building.

This is where you design the “how.” If the goal is to improve objection handling, the plan must include role-playing. If the goal is to improve product knowledge, the plan should include micro-learning modules and call reviews. The key is to link every training activity directly to a specific goal.

AI is exceptionally good at generating these targeted practice materials. Instead of using generic role-play scenarios, you can create hyper-realistic simulations based on the rep’s actual weaknesses.

Use a prompt like this:

“Generate a role-playing scenario for a sales rep who needs to practice handling a ‘we’re happy with our current provider’ objection. The scenario should be for a mid-market SaaS company selling project management software. The prospect is a VP of Operations who is risk-averse. Provide the opening line for the prospect and three follow-up questions the rep should ask to uncover potential dissatisfaction.”

This gives you a ready-to-use script for your next 1:1 coaching session, ensuring the practice is relevant and directly tied to the rep’s development needs.

The Role-Play Revolution

Consistent practice is the key to mastery, but a manager’s time is limited. This is where the AI-powered role-play revolution comes in. An AI chatbot can act as a tireless, low-stakes practice partner for your reps, allowing them to hone their skills on their own time. This is a game-changer for building confidence and muscle memory before a live customer conversation.

The manager’s role shifts from being the sole practice partner to being the architect of the practice sessions. You provide the rep with specific prompts they can use with an AI chatbot (like a GPT model) to simulate real-world sales challenges.

Here are prompts a manager can give their rep to practice with an AI chatbot:

• For Objection Handling: “Act as a skeptical CFO for a mid-sized manufacturing company. I’m selling a cybersecurity solution. Your budget is tight, and you believe your current IT team is sufficient. Challenge me on price, necessity, and ROI. Be difficult but not impossible to convince.”
• For Discovery Practice: “You are a Director of HR at a fast-growing tech company (500+ employees). I’m an Account Executive selling an employee engagement platform. You’re overwhelmed by high attrition rates but are skeptical that software can solve a ‘people problem.’ Answer my discovery questions but be vague at first. I need to earn your trust to get specific information.”
• For Negotiation Drills: “Simulate a negotiation call. I am selling you a 12-month software license for $50,000. You are interested but have been given a mandate to get a 20% discount. Your final offer is $45,000. My walk-away price is $48,000. Let’s negotiate the final price.”

This approach empowers reps to take ownership of their development. They can run these simulations dozens of times, experimenting with different phrases and techniques in a zero-risk environment. When they finally get on a real call, they’re not hoping for a good outcome; they’re executing a skill they’ve already practiced to perfection.

The Feedback Loop: Tracking Progress and Iterating for Success

Here’s a hard truth I’ve learned after coaching hundreds of sales reps: the most beautifully crafted development plan is utterly useless if it sits in a drawer. The real magic isn’t in the plan’s creation; it’s in the relentless, disciplined execution of the follow-up. Most plans fail not because the diagnosis was wrong, but because the treatment lacks consistency. A development plan isn’t a one-time deliverable you create and forget—it’s a living document that must adapt to the rep’s real-world performance, changing territories, and evolving market dynamics.

Without a structured feedback loop, you’re just hoping for improvement. Hope is not a strategy. Consistent follow-up maintains momentum, holds both you and the rep accountable, and provides the critical data needed to tweak the plan for maximum impact.

Establishing a Cadence of Accountability

The weekly check-in is the heartbeat of your coaching plan. But let’s be honest, most of these meetings are poorly executed—they devolve into vague status updates or, worse, manager-led monologues. An effective check-in is frequent, brief, and ruthlessly focused. It’s not a performance review; it’s a working session to solve problems and accelerate progress.

Your goal is to create a safe, predictable space for a candid conversation. To keep it on track, I recommend a simple, three-question framework that you can use every single week:

• Progress Against the Plan: “What is one specific piece of progress you made this week related to your development goals?” (This forces a tangible outcome, not just activity.)
• Roadblocks & Challenges: “What obstacle got in your way, and what did you try to overcome it?” (This shifts focus from blame to problem-solving and initiative.)
• Next Steps & Support: “What is your single most important focus for next week, and what specific support do you need from me to get there?” (This ensures clear ownership and clarifies your role as a coach.)

This structure keeps the conversation forward-looking and empowers the rep to drive the agenda. It transforms you from a micromanager into a strategic partner. Golden Nugget: Always end the check-in by having the rep verbally summarize their key takeaway and next step. This simple act of repetition dramatically increases retention and commitment.

AI Prompts for Progress Tracking and Analysis

A month of weekly check-ins can generate a surprising amount of text. This is where AI becomes your co-pilot, helping you see the forest for the trees. Instead of relying on gut feelings or spotty notes, you can use AI to synthesize this qualitative data and identify objective patterns that might otherwise be missed. This is how you move from reactive coaching to predictive coaching.

By feeding your weekly check-in notes (anonymized, of course) into an AI model, you can quickly surface trends, validate your own observations, and generate ideas for plan modifications. You’re not asking the AI to replace your judgment; you’re using it to augment your pattern-recognition capabilities.

Here are a few powerful prompts you can adapt:

• To identify trends: “Based on these weekly check-in notes for the past month, what are the top 3 areas of progress and the top 2 persistent challenges for this rep? Cite specific examples from the notes.”
• To analyze root causes: “Analyze these notes for mentions of specific activities (e.g., ‘cold calling,’ ‘demo,’ ‘follow-up email’). What is the correlation between the rep’s reported activities and their reported challenges? Identify one potential skill gap.”
• To iterate the plan: “Given the progress and challenges identified above, suggest 3 specific, actionable modifications to the current development plan. For each suggestion, explain the rationale.”

Using prompts like these turns your raw data into strategic intelligence, ensuring your coaching remains relevant and impactful.

Knowing When to Pivot

Even with the best intentions and a solid plan, sometimes progress stalls. The key is recognizing the difference between a temporary dip and a fundamental mismatch. Your feedback loop is the early warning system that tells you when to adjust your course.

Signs that the current plan isn’t working include:

• Stagnation: The rep is completing the tasks but showing no measurable improvement in the target skill or metric for 2-3 consecutive weeks.
• Disengagement: The rep arrives at check-ins unprepared, offers vague answers, or displays a defensive attitude. This often signals a lack of belief in the plan or a deeper motivational issue.
• Blame Shifting: The rep consistently attributes a lack of progress to external factors (bad leads, product issues, marketing) without acknowledging their own role.

When you see these signs, it’s time to pivot the plan, not the person. This means sitting down and re-evaluating the diagnosis. Was the root cause misidentified? Are the training activities mismatched to the rep’s learning style? Is the cadence of accountability too infrequent or too intense?

However, there comes a point where repeated pivots and coaching interventions don’t yield results. If you’ve adjusted the plan multiple times, provided consistent support, and the rep is still missing clear expectations, you must transition from a development-focused approach to a formal performance management process. This isn’t a failure on your part; it’s your responsibility to the rest of the team and to the business. The feedback loop provides the documented evidence you need to make that difficult call with confidence and fairness.

Advanced Applications: Scaling Your Coaching with AI

You’ve successfully diagnosed an underperforming rep and built a targeted development plan. The skills are improving, the metrics are trending up. Now, how do you replicate that success across your entire team without working 80-hour weeks? This is the leap most managers never make—from tactical, one-on-one firefighting to strategic, scalable leadership. AI is the engine that makes this possible, allowing you to act less like a coach for individual players and more like the head coach of a championship team.

From One Rep to the Whole Team: Identifying Systemic Gaps

A single rep missing quota is a performance issue. Five reps missing quota on the same metric is a systemic problem that requires a different solution. The mistake managers make is treating each one as an isolated case, leading to repetitive, inefficient coaching sessions. The advanced approach is to use AI to aggregate and analyze performance data from your entire team to uncover the patterns that are invisible when you look at reps individually.

Instead of manually reviewing 10 different call transcripts for 10 different reps, you can feed the raw data—CRM activity, call transcripts, and performance dashboards—into an AI model and ask it to find the common threads. This isn’t about finding a single “magic bullet”; it’s about identifying the recurring friction points that are holding your entire team back. When you find that 60% of your team struggles with a specific stage in the discovery call, you stop coaching it one-on-one and build a team-wide training module. This is how you multiply your impact.

Example Prompts for Team-Wide Analysis:

Prompt: “Analyze the attached performance data and call transcripts from the last two quarters for my 8-person sales team. Identify the top three most common skill gaps or missed steps that correlate with deals stalling or being lost. For each gap, provide a specific quote from a call transcript as evidence and suggest a single, actionable team-wide training exercise to address it.”

Prompt: “Review our team’s CRM data for the last 90 days. Compare the activity metrics (number of calls, emails, meetings set) of the top 25% of performers against the bottom 25%. Identify the single most significant difference in their daily activity patterns. Hypothesize three reasons for this discrepancy and propose a new workflow or coaching focus to help the bottom 75% adopt this behavior.”

Golden Nugget: I once ran a prompt like this and discovered my junior reps were using 50% more discovery questions than my senior reps, yet their close rates were lower. The AI revealed the seniors were asking better questions, but the juniors were just asking more questions, often repeating the same information. The fix wasn’t more training on questions; it was a new scorecard focused on question quality and active listening, which instantly clarified the standard for the whole team.

Creating a Library of Reusable Coaching Assets

Your expertise as a manager shouldn’t be lost in a single conversation. The most effective leaders build systems that capture and scale their knowledge. Think of AI as your Chief of Staff, tasked with turning your tribal knowledge into a durable, searchable asset library. Every time you run a great role-play, critique a call effectively, or handle a tough objection, that’s a best practice that should be captured and made available to everyone, new hires and veterans alike.

This library becomes the foundation of your team’s continuous training and onboarding. New hires can practice with AI-generated role-play scenarios based on your actual sales playbook. Veterans can use AI-generated scorecards to self-assess their calls before you even listen to them. This frees you up from repetitive training and allows you to focus on high-level strategy and coaching the truly complex situations.

Example Prompts for Building Your Asset Library:

Prompt: “Based on the common objections we’ve identified ([list 3-5 objections]), create a library of 10 role-play scenarios for a new hire. Each scenario should include the customer persona, their stated objection, and two hidden sub-textual concerns. Provide a ‘best practice’ response that addresses both the stated and hidden concerns, and a ‘poor practice’ response that fails.”

Prompt: “Generate a call review scorecard for a ‘Discovery Call.’ Create two versions: a simple 5-point checklist for new hires and a detailed 15-point scorecard for senior reps. For each point on the detailed scorecard, include a ‘Pro-Tip’ that explains why this step is critical for closing enterprise deals.”

Personalizing Coaching at Scale: Tailoring for Different Rep Personas

The one-size-fits-all coaching plan is dead. A 25-year-old new hire who needs structure and encouragement requires a completely different approach than a 15-year veteran who has hit a performance plateau and is resistant to change. The challenge is that creating bespoke plans for each rep is time-prohibitive. AI solves this by allowing you to quickly adapt your coaching framework to different rep personas, ensuring your message lands with maximum impact.

By defining a rep’s persona, you can ask the AI to adjust the tone, structure, and focus of the development plan. This isn’t about stereotyping; it’s about recognizing that different people are motivated by different things and learn in different ways. The goal is to remove friction and make the coaching feel relevant and respectful to the individual.

Example Prompts for Persona-Based Coaching:

Prompt: “I need to create a development plan for a new hire who is technically proficient but struggles with confidence and talking to senior executives. Reframe the standard 3-step development plan (Diagnose, Train, Execute). Adjust the language to be more encouraging and focus on quick wins. Suggest one specific ‘micro-skill’ they can practice in their first week to build confidence.”

Prompt: “My top-performing ‘lone wolf’ rep is hitting their quota but isn’t collaborating with the team and is dismissive of coaching. Draft a coaching conversation framework for me. The goal is to leverage their ambition to show them how adopting a ‘team multiplier’ mindset will be the key to them becoming a future leader (and earning a promotion), without making them feel criticized for their current success.”

Prompt: “I’m coaching a 10-year veteran who has hit a plateau. They know the fundamentals better than anyone. Rewrite the ‘Action’ step of a development plan to focus on ‘advanced micro-habits’ instead of core skills. Suggest three advanced habits they could adopt to break through their plateau, such as teaching a skill to the team or taking on a complex cross-functional project.”

Conclusion: From Underperformer to Top Performer

The journey from identifying a performance gap to building a clear path forward is where management transforms into mentorship. We’ve established that the most effective approach isn’t a single corrective conversation, but a strategic system: diagnose the root cause before you ever sit down, structure the dialogue for collaboration, and build a SMART plan that provides clarity and momentum. Your role is pivotal—you are not just a manager overseeing tasks, but a coach architecting success. This shift from a reactive supervisor to a proactive strategist is what separates good leaders from great ones.

In 2025, leveraging AI in this process isn’t about replacing your judgment; it’s about augmenting your focus. By letting AI handle the heavy lifting of structuring plans and analyzing data points, you free up your most valuable resource—your time and emotional energy. This allows you to invest deeply in the high-value activities that truly drive growth: building trust, navigating complex interpersonal dynamics, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement where every rep feels supported.

Your first actionable step is to put this into practice immediately. This week, before your next 1:1 with an underperforming rep, use the root cause analysis prompt. Simply input the observable data and ask the AI to help you brainstorm potential causes. This small experiment will provide its own proof, transforming your next conversation from a potentially difficult review into a productive, forward-looking coaching session.

Critical Warning

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the first step in fixing underperformance

The first step is a rigorous diagnostic phase to identify the root cause, categorized by the ‘Three P’s’ framework: Problems (skills), Process (workflow), or Psychology (mindset)

Q: How does AI help in sales coaching

AI acts as a strategic co-pilot by structuring feedback, providing unbiased data analysis, and generating specific prompts to diagnose issues and build development plans

Q: Why is structured coaching important

Structured coaching programs are proven to drive 28% higher revenue growth and significantly improve rep retention rates